01. September 2024 · Comments Off on Ag and Rural Caucus for September 2024 · Categories: Committee News, Recent Events

Ag and Rural Caucus for September

Recording link: https://us02web.zoom.us/rec/share/lP8yija1k6JFDiLzdCzmqhVKs4plhrRWx6EymWBsJqUdUSNZvFOhTFecGmrutYVy.7wrWkycJlOPGOLox

Better Practices

6:30 pm Thursday 5 September
LD Primaries – What did we learn?

Roundtable discussion

https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88689149657?pwd=R3dXbFRpYVUyeGVhb3ErTFI0QXlpZz09

Policy Briefing

6:30 pm Thursday 19 September
Voluntary Stewardship Program: Why it is important

Dan Wood, ED, Washington State Dairy Federation
John Stuhlmiller, ED, WA State Water Resources Association

https://us02web.zoom.us/j/85907982157?pwd=MU4vV3E3VGZ5VU02dnhvZjg2b3hKZz09
Paste link into browser.
Whatcom County…Got VSP?

Whatcom County punches above its weight in resource conflicts. The Hirst decision about permit-exempt wells impinging on the Nooksack River’s prior in-stream water right was Whatcom County. The more recent legislative kerfuffle about riparian management zones (buffers) and farmer resistance to property takings centered on Whatcom County. “Another problem, they testified, is that creation of riparian management zones under terms outlined in the bill would take significant amounts of farmland out of production –estimated at 30,000 acres in Whatcom County alone.” And an influential farm advocacy group, Save Family Farming, “has its roots in Whatcom County… In early 2015, dairy farmers in Whatcom County were facing threats of lawsuits from environmental lawyers and a local tribe. The false accusations against dairies by these lawyers…”

I did not intend to draw particular attention to Whatcom County but earlier this month it was reported that “Whatcom County sponsored work to develop a collaborative process called a Solutions Table, but some parties are not willing to participate. The local Watershed Management Board provides a platform for structured settlement discussions, but we need leadership from all sectors to participate and find solutions.“

Out of curiosity I checked whether Whatcom has a VSP. It does not. It is one of twelve counties that in 2011 did not opt in. It has another chance. Last year, SB 5353 re-opened enrollment.

Thursday at 6:30…join Dan Wood and John Stuhlmiller to learn about VSP.

Don
17 September 2024
A Model
 
It is easy to underestimate the significance of VSP. It is commonplace that voluntary farmer compliance to protect the .)environment works better than fighting for years in the courtrooms. As an administrative tool, it is singular in bringing conflicting parties together, and it was seen as a model at the time: “The Program created in the bill is truly voluntary and is unlike anything that has been previously tried in Washington… it may prove to be a model that can be applied in other states.” (Emphasis added.)

Dean Takko’s HB 1886 passed the House 92-5 and the Senate 48-1. The lone Senate dissenter was a Democrat. 

VSP has not removed conflict; it is a means of managing conflict. There remains tension between environmental advocates and farmers. Environmental advocates want to see measurable results documented in exchange for their legal forbearance.  Farmers counter that their contributions on the ground are real but unappreciated and may take time to have measurable effect in the rivers and streams.  Add in the conservation districts who are in the middle and charged with making VSP work for both the environmental community and their farmer clients.

Join John Stuhlmiller and Dan Wood Thursday as we talk about how VSP came to be and how it has evolved.

Don
16 September 2024
A Unique Accord

VSP has its roots in the Swinomish Indian Tribal Community v. Skagit County in 2007. Drawing on the Growth Management Act (1990), the court held that counties were required to regulate agriculture to achieve the GMA protection of critical areas. [Source is VSP website – not court document.]

The Swinomish decision came after the failure of I-933 the previous year. I-933 talked about property rights and regulation. I-933 spoke for private property rights for farmers, among others: “The people find that over the last decade governmental restrictions on the use of property have increased substantially, creating hardships for many, and destroying reasonable expectations of being able to make reasonable beneficial use of property.”

This background of litigation and public initiative led the legislature in 2007 (SB 5248) to enlist the Ruckelshaus Center to come up with a framework to achieve “’a successful agricultural economy and a healthy environment’ for Washingtonians.”

 The names of Dan Wood and John Stuhlmiller were on the Center’s letterhead of its eventual report. John wrote in the Center’s 2010 transmittal letter to the governor:  “The agriculture and critical areas controversy has been long and expensive and will continue to drain resources from valuable efforts to support agriculture and the environment if we do not implement this unique accord.” (emphasis added)

Learn more about how VSP came to be, and listen to Dan and John discuss its life history…Thursday the 19th.

Don
13 September 2024
A Personal Interest

Dean Takko, former state legislator from LD 19, dropped in on our Better Practices session last week. This was not unusual since Dean is a regular participant. He was a bit disappointed, though, because he wanted to hear about VSP. He was an author of the original legislation in 2011 and wanted to know how it is working on the ground.

On Thursday the 19th, Dan Wood and John Stuhlmiller, both keys to the VSP origin story, will help us understand how VSP has worked so far and what is in its future. Dean will be paying attention.

Next up – Swinomish v. Skagit County, and I-933.

Don
10 September 2024
VSP: What is it?

Voluntary Stewardship Program (VSP). What is it? Why did it start? Is it working? Where is it going?

A lot of questions. The good news is that there are answers to at least a couple of the questions.

Thursday the 19th Dan Wood and John Stuhlmiller will brief us on what we know about VSP and what is still open. Dan and John were at the beginning of VSP and you can see their photos under VSP leadership.

You can get a head start on your homework for this Policy Briefing by googling VSP. Otherwise, I will feed you teasers in the run-up to our session.

Don
9 September 2024
State Meeting in Yakima
28 September

Good news. ARC is on the State Meeting agenda. And more good news…Kathie Schutte, Pend Oreille chair, will host this “meet-and-greet” social session. I will be out of the country at the time and Kathie has graciously agreed to sit in for me.

We meet each other on Zoom twice a month for ARC work but it is always good to reinforce with face-to-face contact. Come and shake hands and exchange smiles. Talk about what is happening in your neighborhood. Brain storm possible program topics. Have fun.

Don
7 September 2024

Saturday 28 September 
Time Location
Agriculture and Rural Caucus Meeting 9:00 AM – 10:00 AM Room I

Our Better Practices roundtable is on the first Thursday of each month at 6:30 pm.. Use the link above for 2024.

Our Policy Series is on the third Thursday of each month at 6:30 pm. Use the link above for 2024


Copyright © 2024 Ag and Rural Caucus, All rights reserved.
Ag and Rural Caucus of State Democratic Central Committee
Our mailing address is:
Ag and Rural Caucus
2921 Mud Creek Rd
Waitsburg, WA 99361